Cuckoo Clock Songbird Crafts Renegade Beauty From Raw Chaos

Tune-Yards
WhoKill
4AD

Bird-Brains, the rambunctious 2009 debut album of Tune- Yards’ Merrill Garbus, is a notable example of the creative heights that can be achieved in the absence of formality and restraint: Guitars flailed gracelessly over poorly recorded drums, and every aspect of the recording was bathed in a tinny layer of digital dis- tortion, while the shoddy atmospherics provided the perfect sonic foundation for Garbus’ ramshackle songs; all this creates a compel- ling, unlikely tension between order and disorder that’s become the basis of her sound.

Though the recording quality is miles better than anything off Bird-Brains, WhoKill preserves the beauty-through-ugliness aesthetic of the earlier album. This approach is perhaps best summarized in the manic spoken-word interjection (a common fea- ture of WhoKill) on standout “Riotriot”: “There is a freedom in violence that I don’t understand,” cries Garbus. “And like I’ve never felt before.”

Indeed, WhoKill is characterized more than anything by its aggression. Lead single “Bizness” is an excellent embodiment of this approach: a prominent bass riff is accompanied by vaguely tribal drumming, Garbus’ ever-ecstatic yelping and, eventually, a fantastic saxophone barrage that wouldn’t sound out of place in sax legend John Coltrane’s Ascension. While Coltrane’s heady brand of free jazz is a far cry from Garbus’ earnest blasts of sound, the two share a willingness to abandon established formula.

Garbus does tend to stick to the same basic elements: distorted, ’90s radio-rock guitar, unabashedly loose bass work, layered drum loops and a helluva lot of scream- singing. But whether she’s cooing seductively to a (real or imagined) lover on “Powa” or confessing weak- ness on “Es-So,” Garbus demonstrates a mode of expression that’s fresher, more vital and — most importantly — more fun than almost anything else happening in indie rock today.

More to Discover
Donate to The UCSD Guardian
$210
$500
Contributed
Our Goal

Your donation will support the student journalists at University of California, San Diego. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment, keep printing our papers, and cover our annual website hosting costs.

Donate to The UCSD Guardian
$210
$500
Contributed
Our Goal