The Student News Site of University of California - San Diego

The UCSD Guardian

The Student News Site of University of California - San Diego

The UCSD Guardian

The Student News Site of University of California - San Diego

The UCSD Guardian

Bloom Bash 2024
Thomas Murphy, Co-Webmaster & Associate Photo Editor • Apr 22, 2024
Why I Smoke: 4/20 on Sun God Lawn
Ennis Opal, Staff Writer • Apr 22, 2024
Lunar Legislation: A look ahead
Max Rivett, Staff Writer • Apr 22, 2024
The History and Effects of THC
Kelly Loo, Senior Staff Writer • Apr 22, 2024

The danger of research taking precedence over students’ educational experience

Artwork+by+Ava+Bayley
Artwork by Ava Bayley

As UC San Diego begins to expand its student population, it is time for the university to return to focusing on education just as much as it does research. Currently, there is a large skew financially and philosophically at this institution toward research over education. More resources ought to be invested in education and student life over research.

UCSD is a behemoth in the world of research and is well-established as one of the highest-spending Research and Development universities in the U.S. According to the National Center for Science and Engineering, UCSD was ranked consistently as the top 10 universities for spending on research, leading ahead of schools like Harvard and Stanford. This devotion to the field of research is by no means a negative fact, but it illustrates just how UCSD’s research ranking does not match up with its education ranking. For example, in the US News Ranking, UCSD is a top 10 school in terms of research but is still ranked only 28th overall in Best National Universities.

The founder of the entire field of economics, Adam Smith, states in his 1776 magnum opus “The Wealth of Nations” that there are only three things that truly affect long-term economic growth: natural resources, human labor, and capital. Education invests in labor by boosting its quality and efficiency while research invests in technology. These two things should be balanced accordingly, as neither one outweighs the other, certainly not in a 1:4 ratio for budget spending as it is now (see pie chart below). To balance out this ratio, universities like UCSD need to dedicate more resources toward prioritizing education and creating a better learning experience. Ultimately, UCs — especially UCSD — should not just serve as national laboratories.

The main purpose of any university should be to educate its students and act as an institution that allows for social mobility. Education is what casts away the shrouds of ignorance, propels economic progress, and boosts worker efficiency. Israel Scheffler, one of the fathers of educational philosophy, describes the main purpose of education as a way “to help the learner attain maximum self-sufficiency as economically as possible,” in his most famous work: “Of Human Potential: An Essay in the Philosophy of Education.”

Meanwhile, the educational experience at UCSD is simply not up to par with its fantastic research side. There are never-ending waitlists for in-demand classes, especially pre-major courses like introductory computer science, biology, or chemistry courses that lead to lecture halls crowded with over 500 people. Most notably, the housing shortage, with nearly 2,300 students on the waitlist for a bed, was made worse by the sky-high, off-campus rent in La Jolla. 

Furthermore, this is not an issue limited to UCSD, as many of the other UC schools also suffer from this skew of research over education, most notably UC Berkeley. The university is ranked 5th in Global Research reputation in the U.S. News Rankings but provides housing to only 23% of undergrads, the lowest percentage out of all the UCs. UC Berkeley spends nearly 60% of its budget on salaries for instruction and research (the majority being research), while only 16% on building projects.

Source: https://annualreport.ucsd.edu/2017/ (The most recent UCSD annual fiscal report in this form)

It is easy to make the argument that this is not an allocative issue; that the UCs themselves have no control over this skew, as some of the grant money they receive is dedicated towards research exclusively. Some grants are indeed given by private donors and nonprofits, but this is turning a blind eye to the fact that, generally speaking, educational and research funds come from the same source: the people’s tax money. 

Corporate money makes up only a 6th of UCSD’s total budget — the rest is essentially the people’s money.
Source: https://annualreport.ucsd.edu/2017/

UCSD is a good school with strong academics and a dedicated student population. However, to remain a strong teaching institution, UCSD will need to allocate resources towards the quality of student education and life instead of throwing funds at an already very strong research reputation. UCSD does not need to necessarily halt their research endeavors. Rather, they should take the time to reassess how their students are studying at a university that is becoming rapidly overcrowded and unable to support the student population. It is important to note that in UCSD’s mission statement “educating” comes before “generating knowledge,” and the phrase “student-centered” comes before “research-oriented.” 

Leave a Comment
About the Contributor
Kevin Zhu
Kevin Zhu, Staff Writer
Kevin is a first year Data Science major. He is on par to become the biggest corporate sellout, covering up his actually very artsy inside by presenting himself as a STEM guy. In addition, Kevin also plays 4 instruments, basketball, and is definitely not only 5’7. He likes cliche inspirational quotes and deep movies, so he will quote Camus to end his bio: “In the midst of winter I found within me an invincible summer.”
More to Discover
Donate to The UCSD Guardian
$210
$500
Contributed
Our Goal

Your donation will support the student journalists at University of California, San Diego. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment, keep printing our papers, and cover our annual website hosting costs.

Donate to The UCSD Guardian
$210
$500
Contributed
Our Goal

Comments (0)

All The UCSD Guardian Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *